Up to this point, I have been a pretty loyal royal icing user. It wasn't by choice, it was because it was all I knew. I only recently became aware that there was another option...glaze. Now, most glaze users will say that it is the ONLY thing they will use. And most RI users will say they will ONLY use RI. There are a few that are able to combine the two, but for the most part, it's either the one or the other. The one thing that the two types of icing have in common? Both users can find the other medium to be hard to work with.
I'd been intrigued by glaze for some time, thinking that it was something that I must be missing out on. To be honest, the first time I tried it, I failed miserably. I decided that I was one of those loyal RI users. Glaze was just
too hard to work with! But, since that failed attempt, I have been determined to master glaze! How awesome would that be if I was able to work in BOTH mediums...successfully?! Ohhh, the options! So, last week, I gave glaze another chance. I first re-tried Pam's recipe from
Cookie Crazie. It was a success this time! Then, a Facebook fan, introduced me to a milk-based glaze from Toba Garrett. (
Here is a link to the best version of the recipe I have found.) I tried that recipe just a couple of days ago. And I really liked that one. Today, I tried a third glaze recipe, a second milk-based glaze, from a cookier I found on Cake Central...Sugar Therapy. And after using
this glaze*, I was hooked! Hooked on glaze! I really, REALLY loved it...so much so that I am actually rethinking using my RI for most of my work and switching to glaze being my main medium. And the reasons why are as follows:
My Thoughts on Glaze:
1. It is SUPER easy and SUPER cheap to make. The only ingredients in glaze are powdered sugar, milk (if you choose milk-based), light corn syrup, and flavorings (usually vanilla or almond or a combination of the two). There is no meringue powder which, RI users will agree, can be quite expensive. You simply combine the ingredients, mix for a minute or two and you are DONE! Divide the icing into bowls for coloring, add coloring, add water to thin it out if needed and you are ready to decorate! As for the coloring, you hardly have to use any food coloring. I used just a single drop of Americolor Sky Blue and got this deep shade:
Less coloring also means less money AND less of the "off" taste you can get with RI. Double bonus!
2. It is NOT harder to use than RI. Yes, it can be quite difficult to mix. Get those arm muscles ready. And you will not want to use your dainty bowl scrapers or rubber spatulas. You need some serious hardware (just a really strong stirring utensil) to work with glaze. That is about the hardest part of the whole process. Once the icing is divided and you begin working it, it becomes easier to stir. Especially as you add water to thin it out. I think you really need to treat glaze just like you would your RI. Yes, it is "different", but I would not say harder to work with or even inferior to RI. Just different. BUT, you should not treat it differently. If you use a 10 second RI, you will want to use a 10 second glaze. If you are like me, and you prefer to use a thick piping icing and a really thin (5 second or less) flood icing, then you should make your glaze piping icing equally as thick and your flood icing equally as thin. I prefer using a two consistency method because the piping icing really creates that dam that holds the flood icing in. And even if you wait a minute or two, the flood icing WILL merge with the thicker piping icing. You won't see a seam like you would with RI. As I piped my outline, I may have had to squeeze the bag just a little harder, but it created a smooth and consistent line that was easily positionable. Unlike RI, it IS harder to connect the ends of the outline. You may end up with a point where the two meet, but you can easily tap that down with your finger or even later with a dampened brush. The flood icing acted exactly the same as RI. I like mine quite a bit thinner, so it can just spread out on its own and fill in the holes. While the glaze tends to start drying right away, you still have plenty of time to work with it and not have the "correction" marks you would if you tried to fix your RI. (How many of us have put our finger in the icing or the outline and tried to fix it with RI? With glaze, you just tap it a little, kinda like clay, using a little water on a brush if needed...and it's GONE!)
3.
It dries SUPER shiny. I was using an awful lot of corn syrup in my RI, trying to get more sheen on my cookies. RI can be quite dull in appearance. Some people like it, some people don't. It's nothing a little disco dust or luster dust can't fix! But, if you want a really super shiny surface, you have to go with glaze. Even after drying for HOURS, the surface literally looked like it was still wet! In this picture, you can actually see a bit of a reflection of my kopykake! (This icing was made using Cookie Crazie's
recipe.)

Now, I have to admit that one reason I never tried glaze before, was because I didn't like the look of it. Most glazed cookies I have seen have a "milky" sheen, a translucency that I don't particularly care for. To ME, it just looked unappetizing. (I am not saying that they ARE unappetizing, because I never actually TRIED glaze before. And I am sure it is delicious! It's just a personal preference.) I always thought this "milky" appearance was due to milk being used in the glaze. Well, it turns out that the opposite is actually true! The milk-based glazes are actually opaque, more solid in color. The glazes that don't use milk are the ones that appear to be translucent. I understand that adding some white icing coloring to the glaze could solve that though. Again, it's just a personal preference. It does NOT mean that it is inferior or anything other than just a different "type" of icing. Understanding this difference, the glaze without milk will appear to have more shine than the ones that use milk. (That has been my observation, you may have had another experience.) In this close-up shot of my blue butterfly cookie made with Sugar Therapy's
milk-based glaze, you can see there is no translucent appearance and the shine is not quite as shiny as the pink one above.

4. Glaze has a soft bite. A lot of people don't like RI because of its hard texture after it dries. RI will dry rock hard to the touch, which makes it super for stacking and shipping. Glaze will also dry hard to the touch (the timing depends on how thick you make your flood and how much corn syrup is in your recipe), but unlike RI, it is soft when you bite into it. It has more of a gel quality to it. There is no chalkiness that some people can get with RI and it is not crunchy like RI can be. (Again, this does not mean ALL RI is crunchy or chalky...but it can happen depending on the recipe and the way it is handled during the processing.)
5. The taste is..."somewhat" better than RI. Now, I only say "somewhat" because it really depends on the RI recipe and how much food coloring had to be used to get the color. You DO have to use more food coloring with RI, THAT was one noticeable difference between the two. I only had to use ONE drop of coloring for the blue cookies above and I would have had to use closer to 1/2 teaspoon to get the same color with RI. That alone will help prevent the "off" taste. The meringue powder can be the other culprit when it comes to RI, but I use LOTS of vanilla extract in my RI and I use a LOT of corn syrup, so these added sugary flavorings tend to mask that chemically taste so many don't like. That being said, my own taste test (myself and my husband) found that it is somewhat more pleasant tasting. It didn't seem overwhelmingly better. But, again, taste is subjective...the degree of "better" will depend on what your experience has been with RI.
***
And that's it! Overall, I really liked...LOVED...using glaze! But ONLY after treating it just the same as I would my RI. It is quite different, but shouldn't be thought of as inferior. It's simply another option to dress up your cookies. An option that I look forward to using more! So, those of you loyal RI users who tried glaze and had trouble with it, I encourage you to give it another shot. But remember to use it just like you would your RI. It may take some practice. After all, it has taken me nearly a year to get the consistency and techniques down that I now use for my RI. You may like it, you may not. I for one, am excited at the possibilities! While I haven't crossed over to the "Dark Side" completely, I am enjoying the best of both worlds! My final rating...A+!
I would LOVE to hear your experiences with glaze! And if you have some additional information or if I have something completely WRONG, please let me know. I am not the authority on the subject. I am just sharing my observations. :)
***
*NOTE: I added approximately 1 pound of powdered sugar to this recipe to get to a thick consistency, which I prefer for my piping icing. I divided this thick icing into bowls, colored it and THEN thinned it out as needed.